A federal appeals court found a U.S. Department of Transportation funding decision was improper, protecting New York state from losing over $73.5 million for this fiscal year.
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York judgment dealt a blow to the federal government’s scrutiny of the state’s compliance with issuing and renewing non-domiciled CDLs and commercial learner permits.
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration had said the state was improperly issuing the commercial driving privileges for foreign drivers. But the court’s decision found that determination was incorrect and that the state was in compliance with the rules.
“When we issued these CDLs, we were in compliance,” Zach Miller, VP of government affairs for the industry group Trucking Association of New York, said.
The dispute centered on whether the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles was issuing the licenses and permits beyond when lawful presence documents expired and what federal regulations permitted a state to do. The U.S. DOT suggested that the intent of the law should be considered, but the court rejected that argument.
A panel of three judges found that “states were not required to ensure lawful presence paperwork remained unexpired throughout a CDL’s validity period.”
The FMCSA issued an interim rule in September 2025 and a final rule effective March 16, 2026, that revised federal compliance rules with non-domiciled CDLs and commercial learner permits following state audits and funding threats across the country.
That new rule sought to address the administration’s approach to ensure foreign drivers’ safety records from another country or countries met standards in the U.S.
"Although FMCSA was free to—and later did—go through the rulemaking process to enact new requirements with respect to non-domiciled CDLs, the agency could not withhold federal funding based on a state’s noncompliance with a regulatory requirement that did not exist,” the 2nd Circuit decision said.
The new rule said states cannot issue a non-domiciled CDL or commercial learner permit beyond one year.
That federal rulemaking clashes with New York state’s longstanding practices for how long commercial driver licenses lasted. According to the court, default expiration dates for both CDLs and non-domiciled CDLs was five years for initial issuances and eight years for renewals.
The New York State Attorney General’s Office and New York DMV did not immediately return messages seeking comment about how the state is working under the new framework.
But TANY trucking members have not raised alarm over the new standard or suggested the changes are severely hampering their workforce, Miller said. Fleets have worked to stay ahead of potential conflicts by continuing to recruit, hire and retain safe drivers, he said.
“These are really great career pathways. But it has to be the right way, and we cannot negotiate on safety,” he added.
As of July 2025, New York state had nearly 33,000 non-domiciled CDL and commercial learner permit holders, about 7% of all such commercial licenses and permits in the state, the court noted.
The U.S. DOT didn’t immediately return messages seeking comment on whether it planned to appeal.